PinSay vs BugHerd
PinSay and BugHerd both let people click on a website and leave visual feedback for your team. This comparison uses BugHerd's public pricing page, integrations page, security page and help center. As of November 2026, the two differ in how the AI agent connects, what the plans include, how bugs are captured and where each tool is hosted.
The short version
- Pick PinSay if you use an AI coding agent (Claude Code, Cursor, Codex) and want feedback to go from a click to a local commit, with a free plan, a CLI, an Arabic interface and the option to run on your own server.
- Pick BugHerd if you need a deep two-way Linear integration, video feedback, SSO, or a longer track record.
How they differ
How the AI agent connects
BugHerd offers an MCP server on every plan, marked BETA. It is hosted by BugHerd at https://mcp.bugherd.com/mcp and you sign in with a BugHerd account; its help center says there is no API key. Its public pages do not state a BugHerd CLI.
PinSay has two MCP options: a remote MCP server at https://app.pinsay.dev/mcp (listed in Claude's connector directory; add it with claude mcp add --transport http pinsay https://app.pinsay.dev/mcp), and a local one over stdio (npx @pinsay/cli mcp, 11 tools) where your API key stays in the local CLI process and is never passed to the model. There is also a CLI: npx @pinsay/cli apply builds the apply prompt for any agent that can run a terminal command, and --mark commits and marks the comments applied.
Free plan and pricing
BugHerd lists no free plan. Its plan buttons say “Start free trial”, and the pricing page does not state the trial length. The cheapest plan, Standard, is $50/mo billed monthly or $42/mo billed yearly, with 5 members (as of November 2026).
PinSay has a free plan forever, and you don't need a card to sign up; paid plans have a free trial. The paid plans are Solo at $9/month, Team at $19/month and Agency at $49/month (Launch offer until Dec 31, 2026), with quarterly and yearly billing too.See current prices on the pricing page. See all plans.
Bug capture: console, network and replay
BugHerd's pricing page does not mention console or network logs. Its llms.txt says bug reports automatically attach browser, OS, selector and console error context, and mentions no network logs. Its public pages do not state whether BugHerd records session replays itself; the pricing page lists FullStory and LogRocket as integrations.
In PinSay, bug capture is a project setting, off until the project turns it on, and it is on the Free plan too, with smaller limits on Free. A comment marked as a bug then carries the network calls (method, URL, status, duration, safe headers only), console errors and warnings, uncaught errors, the user's steps and a screenshot per step. Request and response bodies are a separate setting, off by default, with secrets redacted. PinSay does not offer session replay.
What happens after the fix
BugHerd lets people pin comments directly on a live website and automatically captures the screenshot, browser, operating system and CSS selector. It also has a browser extension for annotating any website, and lists video feedback on its plans.
PinSay never pushes code and never deploys. Your agent edits and commits locally, and you review and ship. A comment shows Applied with its commit, then Live after your deploy is reported with npx @pinsay/cli status --deployed.
Arabic and other languages
BugHerd's public pages do not state which interface languages it supports, or whether Arabic or RTL is supported.
PinSay's widget and dashboard work in English and Arabic with full RTL. People can comment in any language; the agent gets a translation and the original stays with the comment. PinSay also takes voice comments.
Integrations, hosting and compliance
BugHerd's integrations page lists Jira and Linear as deep two-way integrations, and GitHub, where tasks can create GitHub issues; GitLab is not listed. It lists Slack and Microsoft Teams; the Slack integration is one-way (BugHerd to Slack) and delivers task notifications, links and updates. Discord is not listed. BugHerd's security page says its hosting providers, Heroku and AWS, maintain SOC 2 and ISO 27001 attestations; a SOC 2 Type II report for BugHerd itself is not stated. SSO is on the Custom plan only, and SAML is not mentioned. Its public pages do not state self-hosting.
PinSay sends comments to Slack, Discord, Microsoft Teams (paid plans), Telegram and webhooks. It also has a two-way sync with GitHub Issues: a comment can open an issue, closing or reopening the issue changes the comment's status, and a comment on the issue comes back as a reply. On its higher paid plans it also has a two-way sync with Jira Cloud: a comment can open a Jira issue, and status and replies sync both ways. PinSay has no Linear integration. It runs in the cloud by default, or on-premise on your own server: a Docker Compose package that works offline and needs a licence file from PinSay (how we handle data). PinSay has no SOC 2 report today.
Comparison table (as of November 2026)
| Feature | PinSay | BugHerd |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Yes, no card | No free plan listed; “Start free trial” buttons, trial length not stated |
| MCP server | Remote at app.pinsay.dev/mcp, or local stdio with 11 tools (key stays local) | Hosted by BugHerd, on every plan, marked BETA |
| CLI | Yes (@pinsay/cli) | Not stated on their public pages |
| Console and network logs | Bug capture, a project setting; on Free too, with smaller limits | Plan not stated; console error context is mentioned, network logs are not |
| Session replay | No | Not stated on their public pages |
| Status after deploy | Applied → Live | Not stated on their public pages |
| Interface languages | English and Arabic (RTL) | Not stated on their public pages |
| Voice comments | Yes | Not stated on their public pages |
| Issue trackers | GitHub Issues and Jira Cloud (higher paid plans), two-way | Jira and Linear (two-way), GitHub; GitLab is not listed |
| Chat and webhooks | Slack, Discord, Microsoft Teams (paid plans), Telegram, webhooks | Slack (one-way notifications) and Microsoft Teams; Discord is not listed |
| SOC 2 Type II | No | Not stated for BugHerd itself; its hosting providers hold SOC 2 and ISO 27001 attestations |
| SSO | Not stated on our public pages | Custom plan only; SAML is not mentioned |
| Hosting | Cloud, or on-premise on your own server (Docker, works offline, licence) | Not stated on their public pages |
When BugHerd is the better choice
- Your team lives in Linear. BugHerd lists deep two-way integrations with Jira and Linear, plus GitHub issue creation and Slack and Microsoft Teams notifications; PinSay has GitHub Issues and Jira Cloud, but no Linear.
- You want comments pinned on the page and video feedback. BugHerd pins comments on live pages with the CSS selector, browser and OS captured automatically, and lists video feedback on its plans.
- You want an MCP server hosted by the vendor on every plan, with a documented guide for each AI client.
- You want a refund promise. BugHerd's pricing page says that if you're not satisfied within 60 days of purchase, you can contact them for a refund of your subscription.
- You want a longer track record. PinSay is young and has no public customer stories yet.
When PinSay fits better
- Your team already works with an AI coding agent and you want each comment to become a local commit you review.
- You want a free plan to start, with no card.
- You want a CLI, and an MCP server you can run locally so your API key never reaches the model.
- Your clients or team write in Arabic, or you need an RTL interface.
- You want each request tracked to Live after deploy.
- You need to run it inside your own network, on your own server.
FAQ
Is PinSay a good BugHerd alternative?
Yes, for teams that want website feedback to go to their own AI coding agent. Both tools collect visual feedback on a website. PinSay hands the exact element to your agent through a CLI or an MCP server, has a free plan and works in Arabic. BugHerd has a deep two-way Linear integration and lists video feedback on its plans.
Does BugHerd work with AI coding agents?
BugHerd offers an MCP server on every plan, marked BETA. It is hosted by BugHerd at https://mcp.bugherd.com/mcp, and you sign in with a BugHerd account. Its public pages do not state a BugHerd CLI.
Does BugHerd have a free plan?
BugHerd lists no free plan. Its plan buttons say “Start free trial”, and the pricing page does not state the trial length. Its cheapest plan, Standard, is $50/mo billed monthly or $42/mo billed yearly (as of November 2026). PinSay has a free plan with no card.
Does BugHerd support Arabic?
BugHerd's public pages do not state Arabic or RTL support, or which interface languages it offers (checked November 2026). PinSay's widget and dashboard work in Arabic with full RTL, and comments can be written in any language.
Can I use PinSay with Jira or Linear?
With Jira, yes; with Linear, no. On its higher paid plans PinSay has a two-way sync with Jira Cloud: a comment can open a Jira issue, and status and replies sync both ways. It also has a two-way sync with GitHub Issues and sends comments to Slack, Discord, Microsoft Teams (paid plans), Telegram and webhooks. If your workflow depends on Linear, BugHerd, which lists a deep two-way Linear integration, is a better fit.
Sources
PinSay facts come from pinsay.dev, the docs at /docs/ and the PinSay code. Facts about BugHerd come from its public pages, as of November 2026:
- BugHerd pricing, checked 19 November 2026
- BugHerd llms.txt, checked 19 November 2026
- BugHerd integrations, checked 19 November 2026
- BugHerd security, checked 19 November 2026
- BugHerd browser extension for annotating websites, checked 19 November 2026
- Getting started with the BugHerd MCP server, BugHerd help center, checked 19 November 2026
- BugHerd MCP, BugHerd help center, checked 19 November 2026
- BugHerd help center sitemap, checked 19 November 2026